[Ns-developers] [ns-2.33] bug in WirelessPhyExt::sendUp()

[Mathieu Lacage]

On Tue, 2008-06-24 at 16:46 -0700, Mathieu Lacage wrote:

> The current model and your proposed modification both seem to fall in
> the category of the more or less arbitrary models which modelize little
> to nothing of the real system and which are there because we don't know
> how to do better (have no experimental data about the statistical
> behavior of the synchronization process at the receiver and the
> subsequent PER). So, is the proposed change worth it ? Maybe, but,  most
> likely, not. I mean, this proposal seems to be about exchanging one kind
> of arbitrary behavior against another kind: yes, your new behavior is
> intuitively potentially more useful/accurate, but I don't trust my
> intuition here. 

erm, and I should have pointed out, that, given your email signature
(@nokia.com), the expectation here is that you would be able to answer
me and say: "oh, but I have hard experimental data which does answer
your concerns" and, in a perfect world, you would be able to share that
experimental data with the mailing-list :) And, then, you would become
my person god on earth for the next couple of months.

regards,
Mathieu